The Best Local Cafés in Cape May and What Makes Them Special
Cape May isn’t just a beach lover’s paradise—it’s also a haven for coffee enthusiasts. Whether you’re in need of a morning caffeine fix, a cozy place to read, or a mid-day pick-me-up, the local café scene has something for everyone. Here’s a look at five standout coffee spots in town and the unique quirks that set them apart.
Magic Brain Café – A Local Staple for Coffee Lovers
Tucked inside the historic Carpenter’s Square Mall, Magic Brain Café is a go-to for locals and visitors alike. Known for its strong espresso and friendly atmosphere, this café serves up everything from rich lattes to refreshing matcha. What makes Magic Brain special? Their chai is a must-try—spicy, smooth, and perfectly balanced. The cozy indoor seating makes it an ideal spot to people-watch or dive into a good book.
What to Try:
• Iced Matcha Latte
• Hot or iced Chai Latte
• Double Espresso for a real wake-up call
Golden Stop – Where Coffee Meets Creativity
One of the newer spots on the Cape May coffee scene, Golden Stop brings a fun, fresh energy to town. Known for its rotating seasonal specials, this café loves to experiment with flavors—think honey lavender lattes in spring and cozy maple cinnamon brews in fall. They also serve delicious homemade pastries, often featuring unique ingredients like cardamom or sea salt.
What to Try:
• Honey Lavender Latte (spring)
• Maple Cinnamon Cold Brew (fall)
• Any of their fresh-baked scones
Nikki’s Café – A Hidden Gem for Breakfast & Coffee
If you’re looking for a café that serves up great coffee with an even better breakfast, Nikki’s Café is the place to be. This laid-back spot is known for its amazing sandwiches and friendly service. Their coffee is smooth and strong, but the real standout here is the house-made syrups, which elevate everything from a classic vanilla latte to a specialty caramel macchiato.
What to Try:
• Chicken Salad Sandwich is unmatched
• House-Made Vanilla Latte
• Cold Brew with Caramel Drizzle
Ostara’s Coffee House – Cozy, Earthy, and Full of Charm
Walking into Ostara’s Coffee House feels like stepping into a warm embrace. This café focuses on organic, locally sourced ingredients and has a cozy, welcoming atmosphere that keeps people coming back. From their herbal-infused lattes to their selection of healthy, homemade treats, Ostara’s is the perfect spot for those looking for a more natural, holistic coffee experience.
What to Try:
• Lavender Honey Latte
• Golden Turmeric Latte
• Vegan Banana Bread
Out There Coffee – Funky Vibes & Exceptional Brews
If you’re looking for a café with personality, Out There Coffee is the place to be. This funky, eclectic spot is known for its experimental drinks and vintage-inspired décor. Their menu includes everything from nitro cold brews to coffee flights, allowing customers to sample different roasts. They also serve a killer espresso tonic—a refreshing, slightly bitter concoction that’s perfect on a hot day.
What to Try:
• Espresso Tonic
• Nitro Cold Brew
• Coffee Flight for the adventurous
Final Sip
Cape May’s coffee scene is as rich and diverse as the town itself. Whether you’re looking for a classic cup of joe, an experimental new drink, or a cozy atmosphere to unwind, these five cafés offer something truly special. Next time you’re in town, grab a cup from one (or all) of these local favorites—you won’t be disappointed.
Have a favorite drink from one of these spots? Let us know in the comments!