Cape May, NJ, is a coastal gem known for its Victorian charm, stunning beaches, and incomparable food scene. But if you're a cocktail enthusiast, you're in for a real treat. This town is home to some of the best cocktail spots on the Jersey Shore, where expert mixologists craft drinks that are as beautiful as they are delicious. Whether you're looking for a classic martini or a creative concoction, here are the top places to enjoy the best cocktails in Cape May.
1. The Ebbitt Room
Nestled within the luxurious Virginia Hotel, The Ebbitt Room is a must-visit for cocktail connoisseurs. Known for its sophisticated ambiance and farm-to-glass philosophy, this upscale bar offers a curated menu of artisanal cocktails that highlight local ingredients. Try their signature "Cape May Collins" for a refreshing twist on a classic, or ask knowledgeable bartenders to surprise you with a custom creation. They never fail to impress.
2. The Brown Room at Congress Hall
Step back in time at The Brown Room, the stylish cocktail lounge at the historic Congress Hall. With its dark wood paneling, plush seating, and a roaring fireplace, this timeless spot exudes old-world elegance. Their cocktail menu is a mix of classic favorites and innovative drinks. The "Ginger Snap," made with bourbon, ginger liqueur, and a hint of cinnamon, is a local favorite that perfectly captures the spirit of Cape May.
3. Mayer’s Tavern
For those who prefer a more laid-back vibe, Mayer’s Tavern is a hidden gem that should be on your radar. Located off the beaten path, this cozy spot offers a relaxed atmosphere and an impressive cocktail menu. Known for their inventive takes on classic drinks, Mayer’s Tavern is the place to go if you're in the mood for something unique. The "Cucumber Mule," made with fresh cucumber, lime, and ginger beer, is a refreshing choice, especially on a warm summer evening.
4. The Rusty Nail
The Rusty Nail, affectionately known as "The Nail," is Cape May's ultimate beach bar. Just steps from the sand, this laid-back spot offers a fun, casual environment perfect for sipping a cocktail after a day at the beach. Their "Painkiller," a tropical blend of rum, coconut, pineapple, and orange juice, is the quintessential summer drink that will have you feeling like you're on an island getaway.
5. The Pier House
The Pier House underwent a stunning renovation in the Winter of 2023. It features two beautiful bars—one indoors with a sophisticated atmosphere reminiscent of the Polo Bar in NYC, and another on the Terrace, where you can feel the ocean breeze, just steps from the beach. The floor-to-ceiling windows are perfect for those cooler, windy nights, allowing you to stay warm while still enjoying the outdoor views. The Pier House is renowned for its Manhattan and Black Cherry Old Fashioned cocktails.
6. Harry’s Ocean Bar & Grille
Located on the rooftop of the Montreal Beach Resort, Harry’s Ocean Bar & Grille offers stunning ocean views and a fantastic cocktail menu to match. The "Harry’s Hurricane," a fruity blend of rum and tropical juices, is the perfect drink to enjoy while watching the sunset over the Atlantic. The relaxed, beachy vibe makes Harry’s a great spot for a casual yet memorable cocktail experience.
Cape May's cocktail scene is as diverse and charming as the town itself. Whether you're in the mood for a refined drink in an elegant setting or a creative concoction in a quirky spot, you'll find plenty of options to satisfy your cravings. So, raise a glass and toast to the good life in Cape May!